The email copied below from Patrick Newman (grey suit, glasses front row of picture above) possibly tells all about the alleged Worthington Group PLC fraud. Revealed on the same day that Companies House in the UK say that Greenland Mining Management Limited is facing Compulsory Strike Off for not filing any Annual Return this might suggest the Nunaminerals deal is ready to collapse.
https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/09408353/filing-history
The leaked emails:
Sent: Monday, February 15, 2016 at 4:00 PM
From: “Patrick Newman” p.newman@greenlandrareearth.com
To: “peterxjames@gmx.co.uk” peterxjames@gmx.co.uk
Subject: Re: To peter james
Hi
My difficulty is frankly that some of the opinions and thoughts I have are best expressed verbally – is there anyone at your end who could talk ?
Otherwise I feel you will not get the context – which is all important!
In a nutshell I never met Whyte – only heard about him through Tom Winnifrith, I was introduced to worthibgton in summer 2014 by my lawyer at Faskens
WRN agreed to lend my company GREP $550k but they failed fully to do this.
They lent 437,500 so we have potentially a claim against them forbalance.110,000
I was told I would be paid a directors salary – at last minute told there was not enough cash and would I take wrn shares instead.
In order not to lose the loan agreement I accepted reluctantly and therefore have not been paid anything ( shares were and remain suspended) I have personally covered lots of the Greenland rare earth projects ltd expenses – of the [437,500] 400,000 went to Nuna as part of the GREP NUna earn in in 2014.
So I remain hugely out of pocket on this.
My colleagues and friends are all professional geologists and specialist in exploration.
We feel seriously damaged by association because of what wrn has proved to be.
Anyway the part payment from wrn came before the winnifrith revelations.
Oleg I think came to am early meeting with aiden. Don’t know him other than that meeting.
I never met any of the wrn directors I understand doug ware is a director of wrn – I just dealt with aiden.
Allan Biggar is somehow associated with wrn I don’t know him other than he was recommended by aiden as a potential director of NunaMinerals in summer 2015.
He is not in the mining industry
Now we turn to nuna and GMM.
By the end of 2014 we (grep) had completed with nuna what everyone from the technical point of view considered a good piece of work.
We were looking forward to working in summer season 2015.
Suddenly I was informed that NunaMinerals which had been introduced by the British foreign office as “representing the interests of the greenland government ” was in financial difficulty.
This came as a huge and unexpected blow.
We thought of nuna as the flagship greenland mining company with strong government support
I now know that the greenland prime ministers office made a special emergency loan to nuna in late 2014 and stated that this must be repaid by end jan. 2015 – this was frankly impossible. When that repayment failed the Govt proposed to convert the loan effectively reducing the other sharehdrrs to virtually nothing.
However the Govt was not able to vote this through because it only had a third of the shares and the other shareholders LD and NY Kredit etx refused.
I was not aware of this . I went to the EGM of Nuna in Nuuk I. Jan 2015. It was clear that if the Govt failed to convert its loan it would call the loan thereby putting nuna into bankruptcy . The officials were not friendly and did not seem to grasp that we had come bona fide only eight weeks before and put money into Nuna!
The govt could have chosen a reasonable course for example it could have stated it would hold the loan on the balance sheet for another year.
As a joint venture partner GREP as planning to put 800k usd into nuna in summer 2015 as the Koreans were planning 700k so cash was actually expected!
Instead and frankly very aggressively the governemt. Tried to pull back its loan although it was quite impossible for Nuna to pay .
The threat to bankrupt nuna would – if if had been acted on – have meant all the nuna minerals licenses at vaga at Hugin and the Korean one at qeqeutusaq would have reverted to the state – in other words the cash put in by GREP and KOREs respectively would have been lost!
Plus all our time
I considered that with my team and we were very unhappy about this as seemed unfair that the government could on the one hand act like a lender ( and a pretty aggressively) and at the same time act as a shareholder and at same time the licensing authority!!! In a nutshell it was not a fair way of proceeding towards the non Governement sharehdrrs and to the creditors ( as GREP we would have a claim against the govt)
We asked who would get out licenses if they were clawed back?
Anyway this was why we formed GMM as a new special purpose vehce with the aim of undertaking a management buy out of nuna
The shareholders were me the geologists and others including the lawyer and CRD took five percent – they are a team of professionals in minkng exploration and one of their goes had been in field in greenland
GMM at that point had no funds but we did have the pledge for the GREP claim and the Koreans ( who were not even properly informed by nuna or by the govt of greenland and who were very upset) pledged their vote to me.
However ( we are now march 2015) we still couldn’t raise the money to pay off the Government debt ( govt insisted on getting its loan lis interest back and would not negotiate a stages payment scheme )
It got to stage when an application for bankruptcy was made
At the last minute literally we secured that nuna would go jnto administration normally you’d only need one Administrator but such was the level of distrust that we were forced to agree two administrators and our Danish proposed Administrator ( award winning top guy) was rejected by govt – we really thought they were trying to grab the assets)
At this stage there were some pretty vicious arguments with Danish foreign ministry and specific civil servants in greenland – I felt that we had been lured into spending money on nuna which had been presented as a state company but now the state was trying to put this company under.
A campaign against me personally started in the Greenlandic media for example bizarrely my idea to give the library in Nuuk a 19 century printed book with woodcuts down by innuit artists – in other words am act of cultural corporate social responsibility was twisted around and I was accused in
A major article of trying to bribe the greenland govt!
I had obviously upset someone .
The sheet absurdity of the accusation was followed by threats on official emails by a civil servant who was the. Fired. Anyway there was a real problem with certain elements of Greenlandic civil service. I have to say the others were fine.
At this point I went back to aiden and explained that unless we had some money to cover mounting legal bills we would simply not be able to keen nuna afloat
Important to note that we had NO plan to take nuna over and we just wanted to do our summer seaSon on the rare earths – suddenly we found ourselves trying to sort out the when company!
The govt had many practical and positive alternatives – it could simply have appointed a professional bank as an advisor to seek to sell Nuna, it could have waived its demand for repayment for a year or two !
We didn’t as GMM really want to acquire Nuna just save our assets.
Deloitte failed spectacularly to behave in an efficient manner and we were basically losing time
And money throughout 2015.
Anyway throughout this I was personally covering the running costs of GMM. The wrn shareholders covered some of the bills
It became impossible to go forward and impossible to retreat .
Finally in nov GMM signed a restricting agreement by the way
I agreed a request from transparency international for them tk get copy
The restructuring agreement provides that govt loan to nuna is paid back in full.
I proposed and it is good that the smaller creditors be paid in full ( larger ones over time) the claims from (grep and Kores we are waiving
On top of the massive legal bills which would have been unnecessary jf the govt had either delayed demands for repayment t ( the legal are more than. The govt loan!!!!) GMM has to find one million pounds
Now as someone who simply wanted to do exploration quietly in greenland which i like I have been associated with Glaswegian gangsters and accused of fraud. This is coming from people who have a problem with worthjngton. At same time I am at receiving end of a campaign from Greenland! SqueeZed in Middle and paying myself for the pleasure!
People who know me know this is absurd and yet as your emails show there is widespread suspicion. As to what I was doing I am happy to speak to all and anyone and as I have made zero from this and am hugely out of pocket I would welcome some acknowledgment for acting in good faith and working professionally
Hope this helps and as I said am happy to speak on phone Patrick
Sent from my iPhone
On 15 Feb 2016, at 12:25, peterxjames@gmx.co.uk wrote:
Dear Mr Newman
Please explain the various issues and background to the Worthington Greenland business by email, as you previously said you would do early this week. My colleagues are expecting that. Given the complexities you refer to yourself, email is certainly the most appropriate method to explain in this case.
Thank you.
Yours sincerely
Peter James
Sent: Monday, February 15, 2016 at 11:03 AM
From: “Patrick Newman” p.newman@greenlandrareearth.com
To: “peterxjames@gmx.co.uk” peterxjames@gmx.co.uk
Subject: Re: To peter james
Better if I explain background. By telephone as it’s a huge amount to document and better and easier to explain and discuss verbally. Maybe you or a colleague of yours would like to call to discuss ?
P
Sent from my iPhone
On 12 Feb 2016, at 18:04, Patrick Newmanp.newman@greenlandrareearth.com wrote:
Ok well will try to set out the various issues early next week
P
Sent from my iPhone
On 12 Feb 2016, at 16:24, peterxjames@gmx.co.uk wrote:
Hello Mr Newman
Your answers and the background are welcome via email.
Yours sincerely
Peter James
Sent: Friday, February 12, 2016 at 4:42 PM
From: “Patrick Newman” p.newman@greenlandrareearth.com
To: “peterxjames@gmx.co.uk” peterxjames@gmx.co.uk
Subject: Re: To peter james
Hi I am planning to be away for a bit next week so if you would like some background do call over next day of two – it is a easier to try to explain the background verbally than put everything down on paper – !
Patrick 07950260026
Sent from my iPhone
On 11 Feb 2016, at 11:22, Patrick Newman p.newman@greenlandrareearth.comwrote:
Hi
My name is Patrick Newman and I would be pleased to give you some background on the Worthington greenland business.
Please give me a call on 07950 260026
Thanks Patrick
Sent from my iPhone